WHEREAS municipalities serve as planning authorities under the Urban and Rural Planning Act, 2000 and are required to participate in appeals arising from municipal planning and development decisions;
WHEREAS the development appeal process can require municipalities to assemble substantial records, dedicate significant staff resources, and obtain professional or legal assistance in responding to appeals;
WHEREAS section 46 of the Urban and Rural Planning Act, 2000 prohibits development and related work from proceeding while an appeal is pending, and the Province currently advises that an appeal may take approximately four to eight months from registration to the scheduling of a hearing;
WHEREAS section 43 of the Act permits an adjudicator to dismiss an appeal without a hearing where the subject matter is outside the adjudicator’s jurisdiction, but municipalities may nevertheless be required to respond to and provide records respecting an appeal before a jurisdictional determination is made; and
WHEREAS an efficient and proportionate appeal process should preserve legitimate appeal rights while minimizing unnecessary costs, delays, and uncertainty for municipalities, applicants, property owners, and residents;
THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED THAT Municipalities Newfoundland and Labrador advocate to the Government of Newfoundland and Labrador for a review and reform of the development appeal process under the Urban and Rural Planning Act, 2000 to improve timeliness, proportionality, and administrative efficiency;
AND BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED THAT the review include:
an early jurisdictional screening process so that appeals that are clearly outside an adjudicator’s jurisdiction can be identified and determined before municipalities are required to prepare comprehensive appeal records;
reasonable and standardized timelines for municipalities and other parties to provide records and submissions;
proportionate documentation requirements based on the nature and complexity of the appeal;
mechanisms for the expedited determination of preliminary or jurisdictional issues;
a review of the automatic stay on development to determine whether an adjudicator should have authority, in appropriate circumstances, to lift or modifythe stay while an appeal is pending; and
appropriate service standards for the scheduling and disposition of appeals.